background image

The Impact of AI on Advice

18 November 2026

Time to read: 6 minutes

It seems you can’t listen to the radio, read a newspaper (do people still do that?), or browse the internet today without hearing how AI is going to change our lives. Whether that is to transform daily routines, reshape the economy through productivity gains or advancing fields like medicine and healthcare. Linked to positive impacts though are fears over the future of jobs, AI generative deepfakes, large scale scams and targeted cyberattacks to list but a few.

As technology improves and its sophistication grows, so the appeal of using AI increases. I am sure many of us have already used AI, whether that’s to research a new household appliance purchase, or predict who is going to win the Championship this season based on results to date. No? Just me then – and it wasn’t Birmingham City!

However, like many things in life, AI output is only as good as the input. For example, using the script, “write a formal, urgent performance review explaining that communication has broken down, expectations are not being met, and we need a serious face-to-face meeting to discuss our future” will elicit a certain response. Now add further context “written to my husband about whose turn it is to do the dishes” and see what difference it makes! It changes a potentially terrifying, career-ending corporate email into an overly dramatic piece of domestic banter. It makes a difference!

Our industry, like many others, is full of talk about how AI will impact the work we perform. What will the profession look like in 2 years, 5 years or even 10 years’ time? What those changes will look like is still to be determined, but I think we can safely say that the future will be different to today. The increasing prevalence and sophistication of AI has led some individuals to conclude they don’t need professional financial advice from a qualified adviser, as AI will produce a plan for them. It is my fears of that prospect that struck me.

Now, I’m in my 50’s and when I look at my peer group, being 50 something doesn’t mean there is a lot of consistency in our circumstances. Consider the potential range of life situations in your 50’s. There will be some welcoming adult children back into the family house after university, others still raising children. Some will be converting a now spare room into a man cave (lady caves are equally permitted).

Another will be quitting a well-paid corporate role after 25+ years to run a highly unprofitable artisan sourdough bakery. Some will be retiring early to travel the world or complete that Interrailing experience from 30 something years ago. Others will continue climbing the corporate ladder with aspirations of reaching a higher plane.

Some will be celebrating 25+ years of marriage, others on a second or third marriage, while still others will be discovering dating apps and dating a 25-year-old. There will be some with the latest activity tracking wearable monitoring their sleep patterns. While others will simply be monitoring how many times they get up in the night to go for a pee.

Some will look like they did in their 30’s; others carrying the weight of years on their shoulders. Some will enjoy perfect physical and mental health. Others will forget why they walked into a room and be unable to sit or stand up without emitting a low-level guttural growl.

Some will have experienced the loss of a parent or both, some will have inherited, some never will. Some will have planned a retirement, some will be regretting not joining the company pension scheme. Some will have savings, some will have none.

What their future holds is equally uncertain. Having made it this far, a 54-year-old has already proven their baseline resilience against half a century of environmental and accidental hazards.

So, where is this rambling leading us, why are we going down this road? Well, I think I’ve demonstrated that the range of possible situations for a 50 something year old is fairly broad and far ranging. There is no one size fits all. So, imagine using AI to prepare your financial plan with a prompt as broad as ‘Assume I am a fifty-something-year-old …’. What range of possible circumstances is AI considering? And how good a financial plan can it produce from that starting point? Remember the quality of the output is only as good as the input!

Financial planning is about so much more than just numbers. It’s highly unique and personal. It’s as much (if not more so) about the soft facts, the things that make each of us ourselves, than it is about the hard facts of age, income, outgoings, assets, liabilities, and so on.

I think it would be folly to exclude or not consider the use of AI in financial services but in my view AI should support, not replace, professional judgment.

Our colleague, Imran Kalam, recently contributed to an article about investment risk and his comments are particularly relevant here. At Colmore Partners, our approach to risk centres on two questions: how much a client could afford to lose financially (their capacity for loss), and how they are likely to feel about uncertainty. To help answer the second, we use the Oxford Risk framework, which looks at how people may react in real situations, alongside our wider understanding of each client’s goals and circumstances.

An example question might be ‘How would you feel if markets fell by 10-20% within a short period?’ This is not an abstract question, it helps to reveal genuine behavioural responses.

By linking a client’s knowledge and experience with their emotional reactions, we can guide them towards decisions that feel both informed and manageable. To what extent could AI create a financial plan that encompasses such personal and intimate knowledge?

I’ve been in financial services long enough to see a few market dips, but let’s take the 2008 Credit Crunch and 2020 Covid-19 pandemic as two key points in time.

You will no doubt remember how volatile markets were during these periods – I can attest from personal experience that when markets fall by the levels experienced here that clients, irrespective of how they answered a question about falls of 10-20% on a risk questionnaire, were naturally worried and wanted reassurance. They wanted to sense check their own feelings with a human being, someone that could answer their questions, show compassion and empathy and hopefully to put them at ease. I’m not saying clients went as far as wanting a hug (I can feel HR over my shoulder here) but they wanted more than AI would be able to provide in such a scenario.

 

This article is for general information only and is aimed at retail clients.

Colmore Partners is an Appointed Representative of Best Practice IFA Group Limited which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority, the registration number is 223112.

This article does not constitute tax, legal or financial advice and should not be relied upon as such. Tax treatment depends on the individual circumstances of each client and may be subject to change in the future. For guidance, seek professional advice.

The links will direct to third-party websites and Colmore Partners is not responsible for the accuracy of the information contained within linked sites.

This article has been reviewed and approved by Best Practice IFA Group Ltd for publication. The views and opinions expressed are those of Colmore Partners and do not necessarily reflect the views of Best Practice IFA Group Limited.

Approved by Best Practice IFA Group Limited on 17/11/2026

Get in Touch

Michael

Hulse

Chartered Financial Planner

Editor

Philipia

Hatziandreou

Marketing Coordinator

Get our updates and insights direct to your inbox

Stay up to date on those topics and news about Colmore Partners by signing up for our newsletter.